Aurora World Plush - Mini Flopsie - ESMERALDA the Cat (8 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Mini Flopsie - ESMERALDA the Cat (8 inch)

$7.99
Aurora World Plush - Mini Flopsie - MOLLY the Orange Tabby Cat (8 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Mini Flopsie - MOLLY the Orange Tabby Cat (8 inch)

$7.99
Aurora World Plush - Mini Flopsie - SUGAR TOO the White Cat (8 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Mini Flopsie - SUGAR TOO the White Cat (8 inch)

$8.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
Aurora World Plush - Mini Flopsie - SUNSHINE TABBY the Cat (8 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Mini Flopsie - SUNSHINE TABBY the Cat (8 inch)

$7.99
Aurora World Plush - Flopsie - ESMERALDA the Calico Cat (12 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Flopsie - ESMERALDA the Calico Cat (12 inch)

$16.99
Aurora World Plush - Flopsie - LILY the Grey Tabby Cat (12 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Flopsie - LILY the Grey Tabby Cat (12 inch)

$15.99
TY Beanie Baby - AMBER the Gold Tabby Cat (7.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - AMBER the Gold Tabby Cat (7.5 inch)

$29.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - ARLENE the Cat ( Garfield Movie Beanie ) (6.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - ARLENE the Cat ( Garfield Movie Beanie ) (6.5 inch)

$11.99
TY Beanie Baby - BEANI the Gray Cat (7 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - BEANI the Gray Cat (7 inch)

$22.99
TY Beanie Baby - BIANCA the White Cat (8 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - BIANCA the White Cat (8 inch)

$18.99
TY Beanie Baby - BOOTIES the Black & White Cat (8 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - BOOTIES the Black & White Cat (8 inch)

$18.99
TY Beanie Baby - BOOTIES the Orange Tabby Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - BOOTIES the Orange Tabby Cat (6 inch)

$59.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - CABARET the Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - CABARET the Cat (6 inch)

$29.99
TY Beanie Baby - CAPPUCCINO the Cat (BBOM May 2003) (6.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - CAPPUCCINO the Cat (BBOM May 2003) (6.5 inch)

$22.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - CARNATION the Pink Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - CARNATION the Pink Cat (6 inch)

$18.99
TY Beanie Baby - CATSBY the Cat (7 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - CATSBY the Cat (7 inch)

$18.99
TY Beanie Baby - CECIL the Zimbabwe Lion (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - CECIL the Zimbabwe Lion (6 inch)

$12.99
TY Beanie Baby - CHIP the Calico Cat (8 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - CHIP the Calico Cat (8 inch)

$24.99
TY Beanie Baby 2.0 - CRICKET the Cat (5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby 2.0 - CRICKET the Cat (5 inch)

$22.99
TY Beanie Baby - CURTSY the Pink Cat (5.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - CURTSY the Pink Cat (5.5 inch)

$24.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - DELILAH the Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - DELILAH the Cat (6 inch)

$16.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - FANCY the White Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - FANCY the White Cat (6 inch)

$24.99
TY Beanie Baby - FIDDLER the Cat (BBOM January 2005) (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - FIDDLER the Cat (BBOM January 2005) (6 inch)

$19.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - FLEUR the Pink Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - FLEUR the Pink Cat (6 inch)

$24.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - FLIP the White Cat (4th Gen hang tag) (7.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - FLIP the White Cat (4th Gen hang tag) (7.5 inch)

$18.99
TY Beanie Baby - FRAIDY the Black Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - FRAIDY the Black Cat (6 inch)

$7.99
TY Beanie Baby - FRISCO the Gray Cat (7 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - FRISCO the Gray Cat (7 inch)

$24.99
TY Beanie Baby - FRISKY the Cat (BBOM September 2005) (5.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - FRISKY the Cat (BBOM September 2005) (5.5 inch)

$18.99
TY Beanie Baby - FUSSY the Cat (5.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - FUSSY the Cat (5.5 inch)

$18.99
TY Beanie Baby - GARFIELD the Cat ( Garfield Movie Beanie ) (6.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - GARFIELD the Cat ( Garfield Movie Beanie ) (6.5 inch)

$16.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - GARFIELD the Cat (COOL CAT) (6.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - GARFIELD the Cat (COOL CAT) (6.5 inch)

$18.99
TY Beanie Baby - GARFIELD the Cat (GOODNIGHT GARFIELD) (8.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - GARFIELD the Cat (GOODNIGHT GARFIELD) (8.5 inch)

$39.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - GARFIELD the Cat (HAPPY VALENTINE'S DAY) (9 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - GARFIELD the Cat (HAPPY VALENTINE'S DAY) (9 inch)

$18.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - GARFIELD the Cat (w/ HEART) (9.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - GARFIELD the Cat (w/ HEART) (9.5 inch)

$29.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - GYPSY the Cat (7.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - GYPSY the Cat (7.5 inch)

$22.99
TY Beanie Baby - HEIRESS the Cat (6.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - HEIRESS the Cat (6.5 inch)

$18.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - HODGES the Cat (6.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - HODGES the Cat (6.5 inch)

$29.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - JAZ the Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - JAZ the Cat (6 inch)

$18.99
TY Beanie Baby - JINXED the Black Cat (BBOM October 2007) (5.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - JINXED the Black Cat (BBOM October 2007) (5.5 inch)

$22.99
TY Beanie Baby - KALEIDOSCOPE the Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - KALEIDOSCOPE the Cat (6 inch)

$18.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - KOOKY the Cat (9 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - KOOKY the Cat (9 inch)

$18.99
TY Beanie Baby - MATTIE the Cat (7 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - MATTIE the Cat (7 inch)

$34.99
TY Beanie Baby - MOONLIGHT the Black Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - MOONLIGHT the Black Cat (6 inch)

$16.99
TY Beanie Baby - MUFF the Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - MUFF the Cat (6 inch)

$18.99
TY Beanie Baby - NERMAL the Cat ( Garfield Movie Beanie ) (6.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - NERMAL the Cat ( Garfield Movie Beanie ) (6.5 inch)

$18.99
TY Beanie Baby - NIP the Gold Cat (7.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - NIP the Gold Cat (7.5 inch)

$11.99
TY Beanie Baby - ORIENT the Siamese Cat (5.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - ORIENT the Siamese Cat (5.5 inch)

$34.99
TY Beanie Baby - PERIWINKLE the Cat (Nick Jr. - Blue's Clues) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - PERIWINKLE the Cat (Nick Jr. - Blue's Clues)

$34.99
TY Beanie Baby - PINKERTON the Pink Cat (7 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - PINKERTON the Pink Cat (7 inch)

$29.99
TY Beanie Baby - PLUFF the Cat (6.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - PLUFF the Cat (6.5 inch)

$24.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - POUNCE the Cat (8 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - POUNCE the Cat (8 inch)

$29.99
TY Beanie Baby - PRANCE the Gray Tabby Cat (8 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - PRANCE the Gray Tabby Cat (8 inch)

$12.99
TY Beanie Baby - PURR the Kitten (7.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - PURR the Kitten (7.5 inch)

$8.99
TY Beanie Baby - PUSS IN BOOTS the Cat (Shrek DVD Exclusive) (8.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - PUSS IN BOOTS the Cat (Shrek DVD Exclusive) (8.5 inch)

$39.99
TY Beanie Baby - PUSS IN BOOTS the Cat (Shrek DVD Exclusive - Holding Candy Cane) (8.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - PUSS IN BOOTS the Cat (Shrek DVD Exclusive - Holding Candy Cane) (8.5 inch)

$34.99
TY Beanie Baby - RHAPSODY the Cat (6.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - RHAPSODY the Cat (6.5 inch)

$34.99
TY Beanie Baby - ROMEO the Orange Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - ROMEO the Orange Cat (6 inch)

$39.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - SCARED-e the Orange Cat (Internet Exclusive) (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - SCARED-e the Orange Cat (Internet Exclusive) (6 inch)

$22.99
TY Beanie Baby 2.0 - SCAREDY the Black Cat (5.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby 2.0 - SCAREDY the Black Cat (5.5 inch)

$12.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - SCAT the Cat (5.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - SCAT the Cat (5.5 inch)

$9.99
TY Beanie Baby - SIAM the Siamese Cat (7 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - SIAM the Siamese Cat (7 inch)

$9.99
TY Beanie Baby - SILVER the Cat (5.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - SILVER the Cat (5.5 inch)

$16.99
TY Beanie Baby - SNIP the Cat (7.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - SNIP the Cat (7.5 inch)

$12.99
TY Beanie Baby - STARLETT the White Cat (6.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - STARLETT the White Cat (6.5 inch)

$19.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - STRIPES the Tiger (8.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - STRIPES the Tiger (8.5 inch)

$6.99
TY Beanie Baby - SUPERSTITION the Black Cat (5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - SUPERSTITION the Black Cat (5 inch)

$9.99
TY Beanie Baby - TABBLES the Kitten (6.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - TABBLES the Kitten (6.5 inch)

$19.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - TABS the Cat (7.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - TABS the Cat (7.5 inch)

$27.99
TY Beanie Baby - TANGLES the Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - TANGLES the Cat (6 inch)

$24.99
TY Beanie Baby - VIOLETTA the Purple Cat (7.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - VIOLETTA the Purple Cat (7.5 inch)

$29.99
TY Beanie Baby - ZIP the Black Cat (7 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - ZIP the Black Cat (7 inch)

$29.99
Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - ZIP the Black Cat (Old Face Version) (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWNMTs) Quick View

Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - ZIP the Black Cat (Old Face Version) (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWNMTs)

$249.99
TY Beanie Buddy - AMBER the Gold Tabby Cat (10 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy - AMBER the Gold Tabby Cat (10 inch)

$29.99
TY Beanie Buddy - BOOTIES the Cat (14 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy - BOOTIES the Cat (14 inch)

$44.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Buddy - CARNATION the Cat (11 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy - CARNATION the Cat (11 inch)

$34.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Buddy - CHIP the Calico Cat (12.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy - CHIP the Calico Cat (12.5 inch)

$24.99
TY Beanie Buddy - DELILAH the Cat (9.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy - DELILAH the Cat (9.5 inch)

$24.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Buddy - EMPRESS the Cat (12.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy - EMPRESS the Cat (12.5 inch)

$29.99
TY Beanie Buddy - FANCY the Cat (9.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy - FANCY the Cat (9.5 inch)

$34.99
TY Beanie Buddy - FLIP the White Cat (9.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy - FLIP the White Cat (9.5 inch)

$39.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Buddy - FRISCO the Cat (10 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy - FRISCO the Cat (10 inch)

$39.99
TY Beanie Buddy - GARFIELD the Cat ( Garfield Movie Promo ) (9.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy - GARFIELD the Cat ( Garfield Movie Promo ) (9.5 inch)

$24.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Buddy - GARFIELD the Cat (Sleeping/Laying Version) Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy - GARFIELD the Cat (Sleeping/Laying Version)

$44.99
TY Beanie Buddy - MATTIE the Cat (11 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy - MATTIE the Cat (11 inch)

$29.99
TY Beanie Buddy - POUNCE the Cat (14.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy - POUNCE the Cat (14.5 inch)

$34.99
TY Beanie Buddy - PURR the Kitten (12 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy - PURR the Kitten (12 inch)

$29.99
TY Beanie Buddy - SIAM the Cat (10 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy - SIAM the Cat (10 inch)

$18.99
TY Beanie Buddy - SILVER the Cat (11 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy - SILVER the Cat (11 inch)

$32.99
TY Beanie Buddy - STARLETT the White Cat (11.5 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy - STARLETT the White Cat (11.5 inch)

$29.99
TY Beanie Buddy - ZIP the Black Cat (9 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy - ZIP the Black Cat (9 inch)

$39.99
TY McDonald's Teenie Beanie - #10 ZIP the Black Cat (1998) (4.5 inch) Quick View

TY McDonald's Teenie Beanie - #10 ZIP the Black Cat (1998) (4.5 inch)

$2.99
TY McDonald's Teenie Beanie - #12 CHIP the Calico Cat (1999) (4.5 inch) Quick View

TY McDonald's Teenie Beanie - #12 CHIP the Calico Cat (1999) (4.5 inch)

$2.99
TY McDonald's Teenie Beanie - #3 FLIP the White Cat (2000) (4.5 inch) Quick View

TY McDonald's Teenie Beanie - #3 FLIP the White Cat (2000) (4.5 inch)

$4.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY McDonald's Teenie Beanie - #18 YAMMY the Cat (2009) (4.5 inch) Quick View

TY McDonald's Teenie Beanie - #18 YAMMY the Cat (2009) (4.5 inch)

$5.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Boos - JINXY the Black Cat Glitter Eyes) (Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - JINXY the Black Cat Glitter Eyes) (Regular Size - 6 inch)

$22.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Boos - KIKI the Grey Tabby Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - KIKI the Grey Tabby Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Regular Size - 6 inch)

$19.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Boos - MUFFIN the Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - MUFFIN the Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Regular Size - 6 inch)

$44.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Boos - PEPPER the Black & White Cat (Solid Eye Color) (Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - PEPPER the Black & White Cat (Solid Eye Color) (Regular Size - 6 inch)

$54.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Boos - TAURI the Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - TAURI the Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Regular Size - 6 inch)

$18.99
TY Beanie Boos - KIKI the grey Tabby Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Medium Size - 9 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - KIKI the grey Tabby Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Medium Size - 9 inch)

$22.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Boos - LINDI the Grey & Purple Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Medium Size - 9 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - LINDI the Grey & Purple Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Medium Size - 9 inch)

$39.99
TY Beanie Boos - FIONA the Blue & Pink Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Jumbo Size - 17 inch) (Limited Excl) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - FIONA the Blue & Pink Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Jumbo Size - 17 inch) (Limited Excl)

$79.99
TY Bow Wow Beanies - GARFIELD the Cat Bite Me (7.5 inch) Quick View

TY Bow Wow Beanies - GARFIELD the Cat Bite Me (7.5 inch)

$29.99
TY Bow Wow Beanies - GARFIELD the Cat Cat's Rule (7.5 inch) Quick View

TY Bow Wow Beanies - GARFIELD the Cat Cat's Rule (7.5 inch)

$29.99
TY Bow Wow Beanies - GARFIELD the Cat Play Nice (7.5 inch) Quick View

TY Bow Wow Beanies - GARFIELD the Cat Play Nice (7.5 inch)

$29.99
TY Bow Wow Beanies - GARFIELD the Cat ( Set of 3 different sayings ) Quick View

TY Bow Wow Beanies - GARFIELD the Cat ( Set of 3 different sayings )

$89.99
TY Pinkys - PURRRSE the Cat Purse Quick View

TY Pinkys - PURRRSE the Cat Purse

$18.99
TY Pinkys - SUGARCAT the Cat ( Beanie Buddy Size ) Quick View

TY Pinkys - SUGARCAT the Cat ( Beanie Buddy Size )

$84.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Attic Treasure - KATRINA the Cat (8.5 inch) Quick View

TY Attic Treasure - KATRINA the Cat (8.5 inch)

$10.99
TY Attic Treasure - POUNCER the Cat (8.5 inch) Quick View

TY Attic Treasure - POUNCER the Cat (8.5 inch)

$11.99
TY Attic Treasure - PURRCY the Cat (8.5 inch) Quick View

TY Attic Treasure - PURRCY the Cat (8.5 inch)

$12.99
TY Attic Treasure - WHISKERS the Cat (8.5 inch) Quick View

TY Attic Treasure - WHISKERS the Cat (8.5 inch)

$7.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
Baby TY - KITTYHUGS the Kitten Quick View

Baby TY - KITTYHUGS the Kitten

$54.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
Baby TY - KUTIE KAT the Cat (8.5 inch) Quick View

Baby TY - KUTIE KAT the Cat (8.5 inch)

$44.99
Baby TY - KUDDLEKITTY the Kitten Quick View

Baby TY - KUDDLEKITTY the Kitten

$27.99
TY Classic Plush - ALACAZAM the Orange Cat (7 inch) Quick View

TY Classic Plush - ALACAZAM the Orange Cat (7 inch)

$9.99
TY Classic Plush - ASHER the Grey Cat Quick View

TY Classic Plush - ASHER the Grey Cat

$44.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Classic Plush - BLOSSOM the Cat Quick View

TY Classic Plush - BLOSSOM the Cat

$27.99
TY Classic Plush - BOOTS the Cat (9 inch) Quick View

TY Classic Plush - BOOTS the Cat (9 inch)

$44.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Classic Plush - CARLEY the Calico Cat (11.5 inch) Quick View

TY Classic Plush - CARLEY the Calico Cat (11.5 inch)

$49.99
TY Classic Plush - CASSIDY the Cat Quick View

TY Classic Plush - CASSIDY the Cat

$34.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Classic Plush - CATALINA the Cat Quick View

TY Classic Plush - CATALINA the Cat

$44.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Classic Plush - CRYSTAL the Cat (Original Version) (11 inch) Quick View

TY Classic Plush - CRYSTAL the Cat (Original Version) (11 inch)

$44.99
TY Classic Plush - DESTINY the White Cat (8 inch) Quick View

TY Classic Plush - DESTINY the White Cat (8 inch)

$39.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Classic Plush - JEWELED the Pink Cat (9.5 inch) Quick View

TY Classic Plush - JEWELED the Pink Cat (9.5 inch)

$59.99
TY Classic Plush - KISSYCAT the Cat (11 inch) Quick View

TY Classic Plush - KISSYCAT the Cat (11 inch)

$15.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Classic Plush - KITTY the Kitten (10.5 inch) Quick View

TY Classic Plush - KITTY the Kitten (10.5 inch)

$39.99
TY Classic Plush - LEXIE the Black & White Cat (8.5 inch) Quick View

TY Classic Plush - LEXIE the Black & White Cat (8.5 inch)

$39.99
TY Classic Plush - LICORICE the Black Cat (14 inch) Quick View

TY Classic Plush - LICORICE the Black Cat (14 inch)

$29.99
TY Classic Plush - MEOWS the Pink Cat (10 inch) Quick View

TY Classic Plush - MEOWS the Pink Cat (10 inch)

$34.99
TY Classic Plush - MOONSTRUCK the Black Cat (11 inch) Quick View

TY Classic Plush - MOONSTRUCK the Black Cat (11 inch)

$74.99
TY Classic Plush - MUFFET the Cat (11 inch) Quick View

TY Classic Plush - MUFFET the Cat (11 inch)

$59.99
TY Classic Plush - MYSTERY the Cat (12 inch) Quick View

TY Classic Plush - MYSTERY the Cat (12 inch)

$29.99
TY Classic Plush - PRISSY the Cat (11 inch) Quick View

TY Classic Plush - PRISSY the Cat (11 inch)

$32.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Classic Plush - ROLLER the Purple Cat (10 inch) Quick View

TY Classic Plush - ROLLER the Purple Cat (10 inch)

$59.99
TY Classic Plush - SMOKEY the Cat (14 inch) Quick View

TY Classic Plush - SMOKEY the Cat (14 inch)

$44.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Classic Plush - SOPHISTICAT the White Cat Quick View

TY Classic Plush - SOPHISTICAT the White Cat

$49.99
TY Classic Plush - TART the White Cat Quick View

TY Classic Plush - TART the White Cat

$49.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Halloweenie Beanie Baby - FRAIDY the Cat (4.5 inch) Quick View

TY Halloweenie Beanie Baby - FRAIDY the Cat (4.5 inch)

$9.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Halloweenie Beanie Baby - FRIGHTS the Black Cat (4 inch) Quick View

TY Halloweenie Beanie Baby - FRIGHTS the Black Cat (4 inch)

$9.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Halloweenie Beanie Baby - MERLIN the Cat (4.5 inch) Quick View

TY Halloweenie Beanie Baby - MERLIN the Cat (4.5 inch)

$6.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Halloweenie Beanie Baby - SCARED-E the Cat (4.5 inch) Quick View

TY Halloweenie Beanie Baby - SCARED-E the Cat (4.5 inch)

$16.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Halloweenie Beanie Baby - SCREAMS the Cat (4 inch) Quick View

TY Halloweenie Beanie Baby - SCREAMS the Cat (4 inch)

$15.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Jingle Beanie Baby - JANGLE the Cat Quick View

TY Jingle Beanie Baby - JANGLE the Cat

$14.99
TY Punkies - KITTY the Lion (9 inch) Quick View

TY Punkies - KITTY the Lion (9 inch)

$9.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Punkies - MAMBO the Cat Quick View

TY Punkies - MAMBO the Cat

$14.99
TY Punkies - SPOOKERS the Cat (Internet Exclusive) (8 inch) Quick View

TY Punkies - SPOOKERS the Cat (Internet Exclusive) (8 inch)

$19.99
TY Pluffies - CATNAP the Lion (10 inch) Quick View

TY Pluffies - CATNAP the Lion (10 inch)

$54.99
TY Pillow Pal - MEOW the Cat (Tan Version) (13.5 inch) Quick View

TY Pillow Pal - MEOW the Cat (Tan Version) (13.5 inch)

$9.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Pillow Pal - PURR the Kitten (14 inch) Quick View

TY Pillow Pal - PURR the Kitten (14 inch)

$9.99
Webkinz Virtual Pet Plush - BLACK CAT (7 inch) Quick View

Webkinz Virtual Pet Plush - BLACK CAT (7 inch)

$39.99
Aurora World Plush - Dr. Seuss - CAT IN THE HAT (8 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Dr. Seuss - CAT IN THE HAT (8 inch)

$8.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
Aurora World Plush - Dr. Seuss Mallows - SET OF 3 (Cat in the Hat, The Lorax & Horton)(2.5 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Dr. Seuss Mallows - SET OF 3 (Cat in the Hat, The Lorax & Horton)(2.5 inch)

$16.95
Aurora World Plush - Dr. Seuss Mallows - CAT IN THE HAT (2.5 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Dr. Seuss Mallows - CAT IN THE HAT (2.5 inch)

$5.99
Aurora World Plush - Dr. Seuss Palm Pals - CAT IN THE HAT (5 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Dr. Seuss Palm Pals - CAT IN THE HAT (5 inch)

$8.99
Aurora World Plush - Pet Mallows - ORANGE TABBY CAT (2.5 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Pet Mallows - ORANGE TABBY CAT (2.5 inch)

$4.99
Aurora World Plush - Mini Flopsie - LILY the Kitty Cat (8 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Mini Flopsie - LILY the Kitty Cat (8 inch)

$7.99
Aurora World Plush - Mini Flopsie - MAYNARD the Black & White Cat (8 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Mini Flopsie - MAYNARD the Black & White Cat (8 inch)

$7.99
Aurora World Plush - Flopsie - BELLA the Birman Cat (12 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Flopsie - BELLA the Birman Cat (12 inch)

$14.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
Aurora World Plush - Flopsie - BOBBY the Bobcat (12 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Flopsie - BOBBY the Bobcat (12 inch)

$15.99
Aurora World Plush - Flopsie - CHESTER the Orange and Brown Striped Cat (12 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Flopsie - CHESTER the Orange and Brown Striped Cat (12 inch)

$15.99
Aurora World Plush - Flopsie - OREO the Black & White Cat (12 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Flopsie - OREO the Black & White Cat (12 inch)

$14.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
Aurora World Plush - Flopsie - TWILIGHT CAT (12 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Flopsie - TWILIGHT CAT (12 inch)

$14.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
Aurora World Plush - Palm Pals - CRICKET CAT (5 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Palm Pals - CRICKET CAT (5 inch)

$7.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
Aurora World Plush - Palm Pals - PEEBS CALICO CAT (5 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Palm Pals - PEEBS CALICO CAT (5 inch)

$7.99
Aurora World Plush - Spudsters - CALLIE CAT (10 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Spudsters - CALLIE CAT (10 inch)

$18.99
TY Beanie Babies - WILD CATS (Set of 10)(Blizzard, Bushy, Canyon, Freckles, Orion +5)(5.5-9 in) Quick View

TY Beanie Babies - WILD CATS (Set of 10)(Blizzard, Bushy, Canyon, Freckles, Orion +5)(5.5-9 in)

$94.95

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - AMBER II the Gold Tabby Cat (8 inch)[2023 Release] Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - AMBER II the Gold Tabby Cat (8 inch)[2023 Release]

$24.99
TY Beanie Baby - AVA the Black & White Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - AVA the Black & White Cat (6 inch)

$34.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby (Beanie Bellies) - BINX the Kitty Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby (Beanie Bellies) - BINX the Kitty Cat (6 inch)

$15.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - The Emoji Movie - CAT HEART EYE (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - The Emoji Movie - CAT HEART EYE (6 inch)

$14.99
TY Beanie Baby - CATCHER the Dalmatian (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - CATCHER the Dalmatian (6 inch)

$9.99
TY Beanie Baby - CHLOE the Cat (Secret Life of Pets) (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - CHLOE the Cat (Secret Life of Pets) (6 inch)

$22.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby (Beanie Bellies) - JENNI the Multicolored Pastel Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby (Beanie Bellies) - JENNI the Multicolored Pastel Cat (6 inch)

$24.99
TY Beanie Baby (Beanie Bellies) - LILLIBELLE the Cat (6 inch)[Original Version - Solid Pink] Quick View

TY Beanie Baby (Beanie Bellies) - LILLIBELLE the Cat (6 inch)[Original Version - Solid Pink]

$12.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby (Beanie Bellies) - MANGO the Gold Tabby Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby (Beanie Bellies) - MANGO the Gold Tabby Cat (6 inch)

$29.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - MISO the Siamese Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - MISO the Siamese Cat (6 inch)

$11.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - MITZI the Tabby Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - MITZI the Tabby Cat (6 inch)

$29.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby (Beanie Bellies) - MORGAN the Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby (Beanie Bellies) - MORGAN the Cat (6 inch)

$19.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - SILVER II the Cat (8 inch) (2023 Release) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - SILVER II the Cat (8 inch) (2023 Release)

$9.99
TY Beanie Baby - YANG the Cat (6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - YANG the Cat (6 inch)

$32.99
TY Beanie Baby - ZIP II the Black Cat (8 inch) (2023 Release) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - ZIP II the Black Cat (8 inch) (2023 Release)

$29.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Buddy (Beanie Bellies) - LILLIBELLE the Pink Cat [Medium Size - 12 inch] Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy (Beanie Bellies) - LILLIBELLE the Pink Cat [Medium Size - 12 inch]

$49.99
TY Beanie Buddy (Beanie Bellies) - MANGO the Gold Tabby Cat (10 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy (Beanie Bellies) - MANGO the Gold Tabby Cat (10 inch)

$34.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Buddy (Beanie Bellies) - MORGAN the Cat (Medium Size - 12 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Buddy (Beanie Bellies) - MORGAN the Cat (Medium Size - 12 inch)

$59.99
TY Beanie Boos - CASSIDY the Speckled Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Key Clip - 3 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - CASSIDY the Speckled Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Key Clip - 3 inch)

$19.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Boos - FIONA the Pink Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Plastic Key Clip - 3 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - FIONA the Pink Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Plastic Key Clip - 3 inch)

$9.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Boos - HEATHER the UniCat (Glitter Eyes) (Plastic Key Clip - 3 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - HEATHER the UniCat (Glitter Eyes) (Plastic Key Clip - 3 inch)

$5.99
TY Beanie Boos - ASHER the UniCat (Glitter Eyes)(Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - ASHER the UniCat (Glitter Eyes)(Regular Size - 6 inch)

$18.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Boos - CASSIDY the Speckled Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - CASSIDY the Speckled Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Regular Size - 6 inch)

$9.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Boos - CHARLOTTE the Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Regular Size - 6 inch) *Limited Exclusive* Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - CHARLOTTE the Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Regular Size - 6 inch) *Limited Exclusive*

$39.99
TY Beanie Boos - FERGUS the Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - FERGUS the Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Regular Size - 6 inch)

$8.99
TY Beanie Boos - FIONA the Pink Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - FIONA the Pink Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Regular Size - 6 inch)

$10.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Boos - HEATHER the UniCat (Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - HEATHER the UniCat (Regular Size - 6 inch)

$11.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Boos - MILENA the Valentine's Kitty Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - MILENA the Valentine's Kitty Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Regular Size - 6 inch)

$24.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Boos - OLEANDER the Halloween Kitty Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - OLEANDER the Halloween Kitty Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Regular Size - 6 inch)

$8.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Boos - OPAL the Kitty Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - OPAL the Kitty Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Regular Size - 6 inch)

$22.99
TY Beanie Boos - PANDORA the Witch Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - PANDORA the Witch Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Regular Size - 6 inch)

$19.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Boos - SHADOW the Black Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - SHADOW the Black Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Regular Size - 6 inch)

$18.99
TY Beanie Boos - CASSIDY the Speckled Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Medium Size - 9 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - CASSIDY the Speckled Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Medium Size - 9 inch)

$14.99
TY Beanie Boos - FIONA the Pink Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Medium Size - 9 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - FIONA the Pink Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Medium Size - 9 inch)

$22.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Boos - HEATHER the UniCat (Glitter Eyes) (Medium Size - 9 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - HEATHER the UniCat (Glitter Eyes) (Medium Size - 9 inch)

$14.99
TY Beanie Boos - OPAL the Kitty Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Medium Size - 9 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - OPAL the Kitty Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Medium Size - 9 inch)

$19.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Boos - SHADOW the Black Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Medium Size - 9 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - SHADOW the Black Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Medium Size - 9 inch)

$24.99
TY Beanie Boos - HEATHER the UniCat (Glitter Eyes)(LARGE Size - 17 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - HEATHER the UniCat (Glitter Eyes)(LARGE Size - 17 inch)

$39.99
TY Beanie Boos - KIKI the Grey Cat (LARGE Size - 17 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - KIKI the Grey Cat (LARGE Size - 17 inch)

$79.99
TY Beanie Boos - Teeny Tys Stackable Sequin Plush - LILAC the Cat (4 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - Teeny Tys Stackable Sequin Plush - LILAC the Cat (4 inch)

$14.99
TY Beanie Boos - Mini Boo Collectible Clips - FIONA the Cat (2 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - Mini Boo Collectible Clips - FIONA the Cat (2 inch)

$12.99
TY Beanie Boos - Mini Boo Collectible Clips - HEATHER the Cat (2 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - Mini Boo Collectible Clips - HEATHER the Cat (2 inch)

$24.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
Disney Bean Bag Plush - CHESHIRE CAT (Alice in Wonderland) (9 inch) Quick View

Disney Bean Bag Plush - CHESHIRE CAT (Alice in Wonderland) (9 inch)

$14.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
Funko Mystery Minis Vinyl Figure - DC Super Heroes & Pets - STREAKY (Supergirl's Cat)(2 inch) Quick View

Funko Mystery Minis Vinyl Figure - DC Super Heroes & Pets - STREAKY (Supergirl's Cat)(2 inch)

$7.99
Funko Mystery Minis Vinyl Figure - Harry Potter - CROOKSHANKS the Cat (2 inch) Quick View

Funko Mystery Minis Vinyl Figure - Harry Potter - CROOKSHANKS the Cat (2 inch)

$22.99
Funko Mystery Mini Plush - Kleptocats Series 2 (Holiday) - GUAPO as Santa Claus (3.5 inch) Quick View

Funko Mystery Mini Plush - Kleptocats Series 2 (Holiday) - GUAPO as Santa Claus (3.5 inch)

$5.99
Funko Mystery Mini Plush - Kleptocats Series 2 (Holiday) - MIME as Elf (3.5 inch) Quick View

Funko Mystery Mini Plush - Kleptocats Series 2 (Holiday) - MIME as Elf (3.5 inch)

$5.99
Adventure Planet Plush Heirloom Collection - FLOPPY STRIPED CATS (Set of 2)(12 inch) Quick View

Adventure Planet Plush Heirloom Collection - FLOPPY STRIPED CATS (Set of 2)(12 inch)

$32.95
Adventure Planet Plush Heirloom Collection - FLOPPY STRIPED CAT (Gold - 12 inch) Quick View

Adventure Planet Plush Heirloom Collection - FLOPPY STRIPED CAT (Gold - 12 inch)

$16.99
Adventure Planet Plush Heirloom Collection - FLOPPY STRIPED CAT (Silver - 12 inch) Quick View

Adventure Planet Plush Heirloom Collection - FLOPPY STRIPED CAT (Silver - 12 inch)

$16.99
Rhode Island Novelty Plush - PLUMP PAL CAT (10 inch) Quick View

Rhode Island Novelty Plush - PLUMP PAL CAT (10 inch)

$8.99
TY Attic Treasures - BESSIE the Black & White Cat (Regular Size - 8 inch) Quick View

TY Attic Treasures - BESSIE the Black & White Cat (Regular Size - 8 inch)

$32.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Attic Treasures - BESSIE the Black & White Cat (Medium Size - 12 inch) Quick View

TY Attic Treasures - BESSIE the Black & White Cat (Medium Size - 12 inch)

$39.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Classic Plush - AL E. KAT the Cat (Large Tag - Orange) Quick View

TY Classic Plush - AL E. KAT the Cat (Large Tag - Orange)

$44.99
TY Classic Plush - APRICOT the Striped Cat (13 inch) Quick View

TY Classic Plush - APRICOT the Striped Cat (13 inch)

$34.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Classic Plush - STRETCH the Cat (13 inch) Quick View

TY Classic Plush - STRETCH the Cat (13 inch)

$34.99
TY Flippables Sequin Plush - WHIMSY the Cat (Plastic Key Clip - 3.5 inch) Quick View

TY Flippables Sequin Plush - WHIMSY the Cat (Plastic Key Clip - 3.5 inch)

$18.99
TY Flippables Sequin Plush - MALIBU the Cat (Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Flippables Sequin Plush - MALIBU the Cat (Regular Size - 6 inch)

$19.99
TY Flippables Sequin Plush - CUPID the Valentine's Cat w/ Heart (Medium Size - 9 inch) Quick View

TY Flippables Sequin Plush - CUPID the Valentine's Cat w/ Heart (Medium Size - 9 inch)

$12.99
TY Flippables Sequin Plush - MALIBU the Cat (Medium Size - 10 inch) Quick View

TY Flippables Sequin Plush - MALIBU the Cat (Medium Size - 10 inch)

$27.99
TY Gear Wristlet - KIKI the Grey Cat (5 inch) Quick View

TY Gear Wristlet - KIKI the Grey Cat (5 inch)

$24.99
TY Halloweenie Beanie Baby - MIDNIGHT the Pumpkin Cat (Plastic Key Clip) Quick View

TY Halloweenie Beanie Baby - MIDNIGHT the Pumpkin Cat (Plastic Key Clip)

$4.99
TY Beanie Baby (Beanie Bellies) - SET OF 4 CATS (Mitzi, Mango, Clawdia & Miso)(Key Clips) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby (Beanie Bellies) - SET OF 4 CATS (Mitzi, Mango, Clawdia & Miso)(Key Clips)

$26.95

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby (Beanie Bellies) - MANGO the Gold Tabby Cat (Plastic Key Clip - 4 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby (Beanie Bellies) - MANGO the Gold Tabby Cat (Plastic Key Clip - 4 inch)

$22.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby (Beanie Bellies) - MISO the Siamese Cat (Plastic Key Clip - 4 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby (Beanie Bellies) - MISO the Siamese Cat (Plastic Key Clip - 4 inch)

$24.99
TY Beanie Baby (Beanie Bellies) - MITZI the Tabby Cat (Plastic Key Clip - 4 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby (Beanie Bellies) - MITZI the Tabby Cat (Plastic Key Clip - 4 inch)

$6.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Puffies - GIZMO the Cat (3 inch) Quick View

TY Puffies - GIZMO the Cat (3 inch)

$7.99
TY Puffies (Beanie Balls) Plush - HEATHER the Cat (3 inch) Quick View

TY Puffies (Beanie Balls) Plush - HEATHER the Cat (3 inch)

$12.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Puffies (Beanie Balls) Plush - MUFFIN the Cat (3 inch) Quick View

TY Puffies (Beanie Balls) Plush - MUFFIN the Cat (3 inch)

$14.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Puffies (Beanie Balls) Plush - MYSTIC the Black Cat (3 inch) Quick View

TY Puffies (Beanie Balls) Plush - MYSTIC the Black Cat (3 inch)

$7.99
TY Puffies (Beanie Balls) Plush - SALEM the Halloween Cat (3 inch) Quick View

TY Puffies (Beanie Balls) Plush - SALEM the Halloween Cat (3 inch)

$5.99
TY Puffies - TABITHA the Orange Cat (3 inch) Quick View

TY Puffies - TABITHA the Orange Cat (3 inch)

$18.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Pluffies - ONYX the Black Cat (Barnes & Noble Exclusive) (7.5 inch) Quick View

TY Pluffies - ONYX the Black Cat (Barnes & Noble Exclusive) (7.5 inch)

$84.99
TY Mini Beanie Squishies - Spring 2022 SET of 4 (Catnip, Hope, Roxie & Bamboo)(3 inch) Quick View

TY Mini Beanie Squishies - Spring 2022 SET of 4 (Catnip, Hope, Roxie & Bamboo)(3 inch)

$17.95
TY Mini Beanie Squishies (Squish-A-Boos) Plush - HEATHER the Cat (3 inch) Quick View

TY Mini Beanie Squishies (Squish-A-Boos) Plush - HEATHER the Cat (3 inch)

$4.99
TY Mini Beanie Squishies (Squish-A-Boos) Plush - KIKI the Grey Tabby Cat (3 inch) Quick View

TY Mini Beanie Squishies (Squish-A-Boos) Plush - KIKI the Grey Tabby Cat (3 inch)

$4.99
TY Beanie Squishies (Squish-A-Boos) Plush - KIRRA the Blue Kitty Cat (10 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Squishies (Squish-A-Boos) Plush - KIRRA the Blue Kitty Cat (10 inch)

$8.99
TY Beanie Squishies (Squish-A-Boos) Plush - SONNY the Cat (10 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Squishies (Squish-A-Boos) Plush - SONNY the Cat (10 inch)

$18.99
TY Squish-A-Boos Plush - HEATHER the UniCat (12 inch) Quick View

TY Squish-A-Boos Plush - HEATHER the UniCat (12 inch)

$15.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Squish-A-Boos Plush - KIKI the Kitty Cat (12 inch) Quick View

TY Squish-A-Boos Plush - KIKI the Kitty Cat (12 inch)

$18.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Bouncers - AZRAEL the Cat (the Smurfs Collection) (3 inch) (Pre-Order ships Spring) Quick View

TY Beanie Bouncers - AZRAEL the Cat (the Smurfs Collection) (3 inch) (Pre-Order ships Spring)

$8.99
TY Beanie Babies - SET OF 3 Spring 2026 Cats (Furley, Melanie & Lady)(Pre-order ships Spring) Quick View

TY Beanie Babies - SET OF 3 Spring 2026 Cats (Furley, Melanie & Lady)(Pre-order ships Spring)

$26.95

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Baby - LADY the Pink Cat (Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - LADY the Pink Cat (Regular Size - 6 inch)

$12.99
TY Beanie Baby - MELANIE the Orange Tabby Cat (Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - MELANIE the Orange Tabby Cat (Regular Size - 6 inch)

$7.99
TY Beanie Baby - FURLEY the Grey & White Cat (Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - FURLEY the Grey & White Cat (Regular Size - 6 inch)

$8.99
TY Beanie Bouncers - PURDY the White Cat [3 inch] Quick View

TY Beanie Bouncers - PURDY the White Cat [3 inch]

$9.99
TY Beanie Boos - LUNA the Halloween Black Cat [Regular Size - 6 inch] Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - LUNA the Halloween Black Cat [Regular Size - 6 inch]

$11.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Boos - PEPPER the Black & White Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Regular Size - 6 inch) *NON-MINT* Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - PEPPER the Black & White Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Regular Size - 6 inch) *NON-MINT*

$39.99
TY Beanie Boos - CASHMERE the White Cat (Solid Eye Color) (Regular Size - 6 inch) *NON-MINT* Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - CASHMERE the White Cat (Solid Eye Color) (Regular Size - 6 inch) *NON-MINT*

$69.99
TY Beanie Boos - MUFFIN the Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Regular Size - 6 inch) *MWCT* Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - MUFFIN the Cat (Glitter Eyes) (Regular Size - 6 inch) *MWCT*

$36.99
TY Beanie Baby - GARFIELD the Cat (STUCK ON YOU) (9 inch) *NON-MINT* Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - GARFIELD the Cat (STUCK ON YOU) (9 inch) *NON-MINT*

$19.99
Aurora World Plush - Spooky Spudsters - CANDY CORN CALICO CAT (10 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Spooky Spudsters - CANDY CORN CALICO CAT (10 inch)

$18.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - CORAL the Ty-Dyed Fish (4th Gen Hang Tag - MWMTs) Quick View

Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - CORAL the Ty-Dyed Fish (4th Gen Hang Tag - MWMTs)

$44.99
TY Beanie Boos - HEATHER the Cat (Glitter Eyes)(LARGE Size - 17 inch) *Version 2 - NO Horn* Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - HEATHER the Cat (Glitter Eyes)(LARGE Size - 17 inch) *Version 2 - NO Horn*

$39.99
TY Beanie Baby - GARFIELD the Cat (GOODNIGHT GARFIELD) (8.5 inch) **MWNMT* Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - GARFIELD the Cat (GOODNIGHT GARFIELD) (8.5 inch) **MWNMT*

$18.99
Funko POP! Disney - The Aristocats Vinyl Figure - MARIE (Diamond Collection) #294 *LOOSE - NM* Quick View

Funko POP! Disney - The Aristocats Vinyl Figure - MARIE (Diamond Collection) #294 *LOOSE - NM*

$27.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
Aurora World Plush - Tasty Peach - CATPUCCINO MEOWCHI (7 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Tasty Peach - CATPUCCINO MEOWCHI (7 inch)

$11.99
TY Beanie Boos - GUMDROP the Teal Cat (Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - GUMDROP the Teal Cat (Regular Size - 6 inch)

$17.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Boos - GIGGLES the Cat in Egg (Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - GIGGLES the Cat in Egg (Regular Size - 6 inch)

$8.99
TY Beanie Bouncers - GEMMA the Multicolor Cat (3 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Bouncers - GEMMA the Multicolor Cat (3 inch)

$11.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Boos - AMELIA the White Cat (Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - AMELIA the White Cat (Regular Size - 6 inch)

$22.99
TY Beanie Bouncers - SAMMY the Siamese Cat [3 inch] Quick View

TY Beanie Bouncers - SAMMY the Siamese Cat [3 inch]

$14.99
TY Beanie Bouncers - PURRY the Tabby Kitty Cat [3 inch] Quick View

TY Beanie Bouncers - PURRY the Tabby Kitty Cat [3 inch]

$8.99
TY Beanie Boos - AMAYA the Pink Kitty Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Regular Size - 6 inch) *Limited Exclusive* Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - AMAYA the Pink Kitty Cat (Glitter Eyes)(Regular Size - 6 inch) *Limited Exclusive*

$13.99
TY Beanie Boos - FIONA the Pink Cat (Plastic Key Clip) (ERROR - HEAD NOT SEWN CORRECTLY) ODDITY Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - FIONA the Pink Cat (Plastic Key Clip) (ERROR - HEAD NOT SEWN CORRECTLY) ODDITY

$11.99
Aurora World Plush - Palm Pals - TWILIGHT BLACK CAT (5 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Palm Pals - TWILIGHT BLACK CAT (5 inch)

$7.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Beanie Squishies (Squish-A-Boos) Plush - SNUGGLES the Cat (10 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Squishies (Squish-A-Boos) Plush - SNUGGLES the Cat (10 inch)

$8.99
TY Beanie Boos - LICORICE the Halloween Black Cat (Regular Size - 6 inch) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - LICORICE the Halloween Black Cat (Regular Size - 6 inch)

$29.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
Aurora World Plush - Spudsters - BELLA BLACK CAT (10 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Spudsters - BELLA BLACK CAT (10 inch)

$18.99
TY Beanie Baby - GARFIELD the Cat (GOODNIGHT GARFIELD) (8.5 inch) *NON-MINT* Quick View

TY Beanie Baby - GARFIELD the Cat (GOODNIGHT GARFIELD) (8.5 inch) *NON-MINT*

$17.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
TY Mini Beanie Squishies - HEATHER the Cat (Key Clip) (w/ Giselle tush tag - ODDITY) Quick View

TY Mini Beanie Squishies - HEATHER the Cat (Key Clip) (w/ Giselle tush tag - ODDITY)

$13.99
TY Beanie Boos - CASSIDY the Cat (Key Clip) (w/ Livvie tush tag - ODDITY) Quick View

TY Beanie Boos - CASSIDY the Cat (Key Clip) (w/ Livvie tush tag - ODDITY)

$14.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
Aurora World Plush - Party Sized Palm Pals - MEOW KITTY (Medium - 8 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Party Sized Palm Pals - MEOW KITTY (Medium - 8 inch)

$14.99
Aurora World Plush - Palm Pals - MEOW KITTY [Clip-On - 4 inch] Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Palm Pals - MEOW KITTY [Clip-On - 4 inch]

$7.99
Aurora World Plush - Palm Pals - SILVER KITTY [Clip-On - 4 inch] Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Palm Pals - SILVER KITTY [Clip-On - 4 inch]

$6.99
Aurora World Plush - Palm Pals - PRISCILLA PRINCESS KITTY (5 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Palm Pals - PRISCILLA PRINCESS KITTY (5 inch)

$7.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
LEGO Minifigure - The LEGO Movie 2 - KITTY POP Quick View

LEGO Minifigure - The LEGO Movie 2 - KITTY POP

$6.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
Aurora World Plush - Palm Pals - DUSTY SIAMESE KITTY (5 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Palm Pals - DUSTY SIAMESE KITTY (5 inch)

$7.99
Aurora World Plush - Palm Pals - SILVER KITTY (5 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Palm Pals - SILVER KITTY (5 inch)

$7.99

 Out of Stock
Email me when available
Aurora World Plush - Palm Pals - MEOW KITTY (5 inch) Quick View

Aurora World Plush - Palm Pals - MEOW KITTY (5 inch)

$7.99