*MARKER* 0

Rare & Hard to find, 1st, 2nd & 3rd Gen Beanies


In this category we have posted Rare, one of a kind, 1st, 2nd or 3rd Generation TY Beanie Babies. These items are among the rarest of all TY Beanies, as they were either extremely limited or retired very quickly. You will see some of the rarest in the world listed right here at BBToyStore.com.

The products in this category will continuously change due to the inventory we get in. We have a quantity of 1 for each listing, If we have multiples of any style you will see more than 1 listing. Condition will vary for each item, click on the item to view a detailed description explaining the Beanie or Tag condition.

We will entertain offers on all high valued items. If you are looking for any rare TY item that is not listed please let us know, we just may be able to get it for you. Since 1998, BBToyStore.com has sold only 100% Real, Authentic TY Beanie Babies full time. Guaranteed!!

Total Products: 117

Sort By:

Pages: [ 1  2  3  ]

Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - BUMBLE the Bee (3rd Gen Hang Tag - KOREAN - MWMT's) Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - BUMBLE the Bee (3rd Gen Hang Tag - KOREAN - MWMT's)
Only $129.99 Quantity:
Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - CHILLY the Bear (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWCT's) Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - CHILLY the Bear (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWCT's)
Only $249.99 Quantity:
Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - HUMPHREY the Camel (2nd Gen Hang Tag - Creased Tag) Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - HUMPHREY the Camel (2nd Gen Hang Tag - Creased Tag)
Only $199.99 Quantity:
Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - HUMPHREY the Camel (No Hang Tag) Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - HUMPHREY the Camel (No Hang Tag)
Only $119.99 Quantity:
Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - PEANUT the Royal Blue Elephant (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 99% Mint) Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - PEANUT the Royal Blue Elephant (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 99% Mint) Ultra Rare!
Only $749.99 Quantity:
Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - TEDDY BROWN - OLD FACE (1st Gen Hang Tag - 98% Mint) Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - TEDDY BROWN - OLD FACE (1st Gen Hang Tag - 98% Mint) Ultra Rare!
Only $599.99 Quantity:
Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - TEDDY JADE - OLD FACE (2nd Gen Hang Tag - MWMT's) Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - TEDDY JADE - OLD FACE (2nd Gen Hang Tag - MWMT's)
Only $499.99 Quantity:
Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - TEDDY MAGENTA - NEW FACE (2nd Gen Hang Tag - 95% Mint) Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - TEDDY MAGENTA - NEW FACE (2nd Gen Hang Tag - 95% Mint)
Only $299.99 Quantity:
Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - TEDDY MAGENTA - OLD FACE (2nd Gen Korean Hang Tag - MWMT's) Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - TEDDY MAGENTA - OLD FACE (2nd Gen Korean Hang Tag - MWMT's)
Only $499.99 Quantity:
Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - TEDDY TEAL - NEW FACE (2nd Gen Hang Tag - MWCT's) Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - TEDDY TEAL - NEW FACE (2nd Gen Hang Tag - MWCT's)
Only $199.99 Quantity:
Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - TRAP the Mouse (3rd Gen GERMAN Hang Tag - MWMT's) Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - TRAP the Mouse (3rd Gen GERMAN Hang Tag - MWMT's)
Only $299.99
Wait List
Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - ZIP the Black Cat (White Face Version) (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWMT's) Authenticated TY Beanie Baby - ZIP the Black Cat (White Face Version) (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWMT's)
Only $119.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - AI the Bear ( w/ Extra Motomachi Hang Tag ) (Japan Exclusive) TY Beanie Baby - AI the Bear ( w/ Extra Motomachi Hang Tag ) (Japan Exclusive)
Only $59.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - BALDY the Eagle (w/ Commemorative Event Card - 1/17/98) Box Included TY Beanie Baby - BALDY the Eagle (w/ Commemorative Event Card - 1/17/98) Box Included
Only $39.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - BEARON the Bear (Red Version) *w/ Midwest Airlines Tag* TY Beanie Baby - BEARON the Bear (Red Version) *w/ Midwest Airlines Tag*
Only $19.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - BONGO the Monkey (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 98% Mint) TY Beanie Baby - BONGO the Monkey (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 98% Mint)
Only $19.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - BRITANNIA the Bear (w/ Patch Flag - Made in Indonesia) MWMT's TY Beanie Baby - BRITANNIA the Bear (w/ Patch Flag - Made in Indonesia) MWMT's
Only $39.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - BRONTY the Dinosaur (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWCT's) TY Beanie Baby - BRONTY the Dinosaur (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWCT's)
Only $99.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - BUCKY the Beaver (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 99% Mint) TY Beanie Baby - BUCKY the Beaver (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 99% Mint)
Only $19.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - BUMBLE the Bee (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 99% Mint) TY Beanie Baby - BUMBLE the Bee (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 99% Mint)
Only $89.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - BUMBLE the Bee (No Hang Tag) TY Beanie Baby - BUMBLE the Bee (No Hang Tag)
Only $29.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - CALIFORNIA POPPY the Bear ( w/ Knott's Berry Farm Tag ) TY Beanie Baby - CALIFORNIA POPPY the Bear ( w/ Knott's Berry Farm Tag )
Only $19.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - CAW the Black Crow (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWMT's) KOREAN VERSION TY Beanie Baby - CAW the Black Crow (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWMT's) KOREAN VERSION
Only $119.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - CAW the Black Crow (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 99% Mint) TY Beanie Baby - CAW the Black Crow (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 99% Mint)
Only $89.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - CAW the Black Crow (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWMT's) TY Beanie Baby - CAW the Black Crow (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWMT's)
Only $59.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - CHILLY the Polar Bear (No Hang Tag) TY Beanie Baby - CHILLY the Polar Bear (No Hang Tag)
Only $99.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - CHILLY the POLAR BEAR (No Hang Tag) TY Beanie Baby - CHILLY the POLAR BEAR (No Hang Tag)
Only $59.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - CHOPS the Lamb (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 99% Mint) TY Beanie Baby - CHOPS the Lamb (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 99% Mint)
Only $29.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - CUBBIE the Bear (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWCT's) TY Beanie Baby - CUBBIE the Bear (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWCT's)
Only $14.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - DAISY the Cow (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWNMT's) TY Beanie Baby - DAISY the Cow (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWNMT's)
Only $14.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - DERBY 132 the Horse ( Kentucky Derby version w/extra hang tag ) TY Beanie Baby - DERBY 132 the Horse ( Kentucky Derby version w/extra hang tag )
Only $9.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - DIGGER the Crab (Orange Version) (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWMT's) TY Beanie Baby - DIGGER the Crab (Orange Version) (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWMT's)
Only $99.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - FLASH the Dolphin (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 99% Mint) TY Beanie Baby - FLASH the Dolphin (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 99% Mint)
Only $34.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - FLIP the Cat (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWMT's) TY Beanie Baby - FLIP the Cat (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWMT's)
Only $29.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - FLUTTER the Butterfly (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 95% Mint) TY Beanie Baby - FLUTTER the Butterfly (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 95% Mint)
Only $89.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - FLUTTER the Butterfly (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 99% Mint) TY Beanie Baby - FLUTTER the Butterfly (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 99% Mint)
Only $99.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - FLUTTER the Butterfly (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 99% Mint) TY Beanie Baby - FLUTTER the Butterfly (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 99% Mint)
Only $99.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - FLUTTER the Butterfly (No Hang Tag) TY Beanie Baby - FLUTTER the Butterfly (No Hang Tag)
Only $34.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - GARCIA the Ty-Dyed Bear (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 99% Mint) TY Beanie Baby - GARCIA the Ty-Dyed Bear (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 99% Mint)
Only $59.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - GOLDIE the Goldfish (3rd Gen Hang Tag - Near Mint) TY Beanie Baby - GOLDIE the Goldfish (3rd Gen Hang Tag - Near Mint)
Only $24.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - GRUNT the Razorback (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 95% Mint) TY Beanie Baby - GRUNT the Razorback (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 95% Mint)
Only $19.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - HAPPY the Hippo (Grey Version) (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWNMT's) TY Beanie Baby - HAPPY the Hippo (Grey Version) (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWNMT's)
Only $89.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - HAPPY the Hippo (Purple Version) (3rd Gen Hang Tag - Creased) TY Beanie Baby - HAPPY the Hippo (Purple Version) (3rd Gen Hang Tag - Creased)
Only $39.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - HOOT the Owl (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 99% Mint) TY Beanie Baby - HOOT the Owl (3rd Gen Hang Tag - 99% Mint)
Only $29.99 Quantity:
TY Beanie Baby - HUMPHREY the Camel (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWCT's) TY Beanie Baby - HUMPHREY the Camel (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWCT's)
Only $159.99 Quantity:

 



Ordering Shipping Rates & Times Returns & Cancellations Privacy & Security Other Information